• Guest
HabraHabr
  • Main
  • Users

  • Development
    • Programming
    • Information Security
    • Website development
    • JavaScript
    • Game development
    • Open source
    • Developed for Android
    • Machine learning
    • Abnormal programming
    • Java
    • Python
    • Development of mobile applications
    • Analysis and design of systems
    • .NET
    • Mathematics
    • Algorithms
    • C#
    • System Programming
    • C++
    • C
    • Go
    • PHP
    • Reverse engineering
    • Assembler
    • Development under Linux
    • Big Data
    • Rust
    • Cryptography
    • Entertaining problems
    • Testing of IT systems
    • Testing Web Services
    • HTML
    • Programming microcontrollers
    • API
    • High performance
    • Developed for iOS
    • CSS
    • Industrial Programming
    • Development under Windows
    • Image processing
    • Compilers
    • FPGA
    • Professional literature
    • OpenStreetMap
    • Google Chrome
    • Data Mining
    • PostgreSQL
    • Development of robotics
    • Visualization of data
    • Angular
    • ReactJS
    • Search technologies
    • Debugging
    • Test mobile applications
    • Browsers
    • Designing and refactoring
    • IT Standards
    • Solidity
    • Node.JS
    • Git
    • LaTeX
    • SQL
    • Haskell
    • Unreal Engine
    • Unity3D
    • Development for the Internet of things
    • Functional Programming
    • Amazon Web Services
    • Google Cloud Platform
    • Development under AR and VR
    • Assembly systems
    • Version control systems
    • Kotlin
    • R
    • CAD/CAM
    • Customer Optimization
    • Development of communication systems
    • Microsoft Azure
    • Perfect code
    • Atlassian
    • Visual Studio
    • NoSQL
    • Yii
    • Mono и Moonlight
    • Parallel Programming
    • Asterisk
    • Yandex API
    • WordPress
    • Sports programming
    • Lua
    • Microsoft SQL Server
    • Payment systems
    • TypeScript
    • Scala
    • Google API
    • Development of data transmission systems
    • XML
    • Regular expressions
    • Development under Tizen
    • Swift
    • MySQL
    • Geoinformation services
    • Global Positioning Systems
    • Qt
    • Dart
    • Django
    • Development for Office 365
    • Erlang/OTP
    • GPGPU
    • Eclipse
    • Maps API
    • Testing games
    • Browser Extensions
    • 1C-Bitrix
    • Development under e-commerce
    • Xamarin
    • Xcode
    • Development under Windows Phone
    • Semantics
    • CMS
    • VueJS
    • GitHub
    • Open data
    • Sphinx
    • Ruby on Rails
    • Ruby
    • Symfony
    • Drupal
    • Messaging Systems
    • CTF
    • SaaS / S+S
    • SharePoint
    • jQuery
    • Puppet
    • Firefox
    • Elm
    • MODX
    • Billing systems
    • Graphical shells
    • Kodobred
    • MongoDB
    • SCADA
    • Hadoop
    • Gradle
    • Clojure
    • F#
    • CoffeeScript
    • Matlab
    • Phalcon
    • Development under Sailfish OS
    • Magento
    • Elixir/Phoenix
    • Microsoft Edge
    • Layout of letters
    • Development for OS X
    • Forth
    • Smalltalk
    • Julia
    • Laravel
    • WebGL
    • Meteor.JS
    • Firebird/Interbase
    • SQLite
    • D
    • Mesh-networks
    • I2P
    • Derby.js
    • Emacs
    • Development under Bada
    • Mercurial
    • UML Design
    • Objective C
    • Fortran
    • Cocoa
    • Cobol
    • Apache Flex
    • Action Script
    • Joomla
    • IIS
    • Twitter API
    • Vkontakte API
    • Facebook API
    • Microsoft Access
    • PDF
    • Prolog
    • GTK+
    • LabVIEW
    • Brainfuck
    • Cubrid
    • Canvas
    • Doctrine ORM
    • Google App Engine
    • Twisted
    • XSLT
    • TDD
    • Small Basic
    • Kohana
    • Development for Java ME
    • LiveStreet
    • MooTools
    • Adobe Flash
    • GreaseMonkey
    • INFOLUST
    • Groovy & Grails
    • Lisp
    • Delphi
    • Zend Framework
    • ExtJS / Sencha Library
    • Internet Explorer
    • CodeIgniter
    • Silverlight
    • Google Web Toolkit
    • CakePHP
    • Safari
    • Opera
    • Microformats
    • Ajax
    • VIM
  • Administration
    • System administration
    • IT Infrastructure
    • *nix
    • Network technologies
    • DevOps
    • Server Administration
    • Cloud computing
    • Configuring Linux
    • Wireless technologies
    • Virtualization
    • Hosting
    • Data storage
    • Decentralized networks
    • Database Administration
    • Data Warehousing
    • Communication standards
    • PowerShell
    • Backup
    • Cisco
    • Nginx
    • Antivirus protection
    • DNS
    • Server Optimization
    • Data recovery
    • Apache
    • Spam and antispam
    • Data Compression
    • SAN
    • IPv6
    • Fidonet
    • IPTV
    • Shells
    • Administering domain names
  • Design
    • Interfaces
    • Web design
    • Working with sound
    • Usability
    • Graphic design
    • Design Games
    • Mobile App Design
    • Working with 3D-graphics
    • Typography
    • Working with video
    • Work with vector graphics
    • Accessibility
    • Prototyping
    • CGI (graphics)
    • Computer Animation
    • Working with icons
  • Control
    • Careers in the IT industry
    • Project management
    • Development Management
    • Personnel Management
    • Product Management
    • Start-up development
    • Managing the community
    • Service Desk
    • GTD
    • IT Terminology
    • Agile
    • Business Models
    • Legislation and IT-business
    • Sales management
    • CRM-systems
    • Product localization
    • ECM / EDS
    • Freelance
    • Venture investments
    • ERP-systems
    • Help Desk Software
    • Media management
    • Patenting
    • E-commerce management
    • Creative Commons
  • Marketing
    • Conferences
    • Promotion of games
    • Internet Marketing
    • Search Engine Optimization
    • Web Analytics
    • Monetize Web services
    • Content marketing
    • Monetization of IT systems
    • Monetize mobile apps
    • Mobile App Analytics
    • Growth Hacking
    • Branding
    • Monetize Games
    • Display ads
    • Contextual advertising
    • Increase Conversion Rate
  • Sundry
    • Reading room
    • Educational process in IT
    • Research and forecasts in IT
    • Finance in IT
    • Hakatonas
    • IT emigration
    • Education abroad
    • Lumber room
    • I'm on my way

France demands to make the "right to oblivion" global - on what it can be affected by

The French organization CNIL , dealing with the protection of personal data in the country, demanded that Google extend the "right to oblivion" to the whole world. The regulator wants the links removed from the French version to be hidden in versions of Google for other countries.
 
 
IT giant did not agree with this requirement, because the dispute between Google and CNIL went to the hall of the Court of Justice of the European Union. Next, we understand the essence of the conflict.
 
 
France demands to make the "right to oblivion" global - on what it can be affected by

 
/photo Mounirzok CC
 
 

What is the right to oblivion


 
Right to oblivion is active. in the EU since 2014. EU citizens can send a request to Google with a request to hide specific information from the SERP. The law allows you to hide incomplete, irrelevant or knowingly false data about a person.
 
 
Entered in May this year by virtue of the GDPR has expanded understanding rights to oblivion. Now EU citizens can request to remove links from the SERP if:
 
 
 
they object to their treatment;
 
this information was obtained without their consent;
 
permission to process personal data was withdrawn.
 
 
The precedent for taking the right to oblivion was litigation in 200? when a certain Mario Gonzalez (Mario González) found , that the Google search engine on the request on his behalf issues court notices of twenty years ago, published by the Spanish newspaper. The trial lasted five years, but then the court nevertheless took the side of Gonzalez.
 
 
Google each request considers individually. In total, in the period from 2014 (since the adoption of the law) through 201? the company received 2.5 million requests for information removal, with 89% of applications received from individuals, and not from public persons.
 
 

Proceedings between Google and CNIL


 
In 201? CNIL demanded that Google remove links under the law on the right to oblivion, not only for European versions of the search engine, but for the whole world. As a half-measure, the IT giant proposed to hide links in all domains when searching from French IP addresses.
 
 
CNIL this solution seemed insufficient: the national commission ordered Google to remove the search results for countries outside the European Union. The American company did not agree with this requirement and received a fine of 100 thousand euros.
 
 
After that, Google filed a lawsuit against CNIL in the French State Council. The Council found it difficult to answer the case, since it concerns the international European law. Therefore, claim crossed in the highest judicial body of the EU - the Court of the European Union.
 
 
The meeting was over on September 11. It is expected that the solution will be in the beginning of 2019.
 
 
 
/photo Katarina Dzurekova CC
 
 

Opinions and arguments of the parties


 
Viewpoint CNIL

 
CNIL insists , that her claim to Google can not be considered an attempt to apply French laws outside the country. Representatives of the organization say that they only require "the observance of European laws by non-European companies offering their services to the EU."
 
 
CNIL notes that for the "full" execution of the right to oblivion, it is necessary to delete data from the results of issuance for all countries. Otherwise, EU citizens will still be able to access them if they use VPN services.
 
 
View Google

 
The company believes that European regulators should not define the "look and feel" and content of websites for users around the world. The IT giant in this matter is supported by the human rights organization Article 1? which deals with issues of free access to information.
 
 
Former general counsel of Google Daphne Keller (Daphne Keller) says , that this case can cause the governments of other countries to influence the content of Internet platforms for the whole world. If the precedent is fixed, then it is not known how long it will take before other states make such demands. Potentially, this approach can negatively affect the freedom of speech on the Web.
 
 
The Committee of Reporters for Freedom of the Press (RCFP) agreed with this opinion. Organization noted , that such application of the concept of the right to oblivion is contrary to international law and violates people's freedoms.
 
 

Probable outcome is


 
As we have already said, the final decision of the court will be known only after a few months. But Daphne Keller said that the likelihood of losing to Google is quite high. Earlier, the lawyer participated in the search engine against a Canadian company that required Google to remove links to confidential information about its activities for all versions of the site.
 
 
The Canadian court ruled that the IT giant must hide the necessary information from the issuance. And although later this case was considered in the US court, which took the opposite decision, it did not affect the initial decision in any way. Daphne believes that a similar situation can occur in the CNIL case.
 
 
While it is unclear what will Google do when defeated in court. When the Wall Street Journal tried to get a comment from the company's representatives, they refused to expand on this topic. It is likely that the decision in favor of CNIL will change the mechanisms of interaction between the regulators of countries with online services and will affect the "amount" of content presented on the Internet.
 
 
 
P.S. Additional reading in our blog about IaaS:
 
 
 
How to process PD in the cloud and not violate the law
 
What counts PD from the point of view of the Russian regulator
 
PD in the cloud: understand the responsibilities of the customer and the cloud provider
 
 
P.P.S. Posts on the topic in our blog on Habré:
 
 
 
Three months later: how GDPR affected the work of cookies
 
The American analogue of the GDPR: what you need to know about the act CCPA
 

It may be interesting

  • Comments
  • About article
  • Similar news
This publication has no comments.

weber

Author

22-09-2018, 23:23

Publication Date

Media management / IT Standards / Global Positioning Systems

Category
  • Comments: 0
  • Views: 318
Six tips for successfully launching the
In India, a new draft law on the
The dispute about the "right to
In the EU, the new regulations for the
3 years of "right to forget": Google
Who's there? In the European Union
Write a comment
Name:*
E-Mail:


Comments
Wow Tastic UK offers a huge range of toys, presents, and gadgets for kids and adults. Discover our great range of fun and unusual toys for baby and toddlers. Check Out: Gadgets for Kids
Today, 19:21

noorseo

Nice information, valuable and excellent design, as share good stuff with good ideas and concepts, lots of great information and inspiraopencarttion, both of which I need, thanks to offer such a helpful information here.

Awesome blog. I enjoyed reading your articles. This is truly a great read for me. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work!
메리트카지노

Really nice and interesting post. I was looking for this kind of information and enjoyed reading this one. Keep posting. Thanks for sharing.

메리트카지노
Today, 18:33

taxiseo2

This is a wonderful article, Given so much info in it, These type of articles keeps the users interest in the website, and keep on sharing more ... good luck.

opencart eticaret

This is a wonderful article, Given so much info in it, These type of articles keeps the users interest in the website, and keep on sharing more ... good luck.

메리트카지노
Today, 18:27

taxiseo2

I really loved reading your blog. It was very well authored and easy to undertand. Unlike additional blogs I have read which are really not tht good. I also found your posts very interesting. In fact after reading. I had to go show it to my friend and he ejoyed it as well!seo toronto



Hey what a brilliant post I have come across and believe me I have been searching out for this similar kind of post for past a week and hardly came across this. Thank you very much and will look for more postings from you. [Url = https: //mtsoul.net] 먹튀 검증 [/ url]

Today, 16:41

raymond weber

I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don't know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often.먹튀검증

Today, 15:58

raymond weber

Adv
Website for web developers. New scripts, best ideas, programming tips. How to write a script for you here, we have a lot of information about various programming languages. You are a webmaster or a beginner programmer, it does not matter, useful articles will help to make your favorite business faster.

Login

Registration Forgot password